SAE CSC2004 Final Score

       

Fuel

         

Cold

   
 

Paper

Static

Cost

Economy

Oral

Noise

Acceleration

Braking

Emissions

Start

Handling

Penalties

#1 University of Idaho

84.9

38.0

12.9

0.0

75.8

0.0

0.0

0.0

___

0.0

0.0

-125.0

#2 Michigan Technological University

83.5

41.9

31.7

0.0

80.5

300.0

89.7

65.3

275.8

0.0

31.3

0.0

#3 Kettering University

85.1

41.8

16.1

0.0

65.3

273.8

95.6

45.7

0.0

0.0

44.7

0.0

#4 Colorado State University

88.7

41.9

17.8

0.0

73.3

222.4

71.4

54.2

0.0

50.0

0.0

0.0

#5 University at Buffalo, SUNY

70.1

44.3

13.8

0.0

71.3

197.3

83.3

30.4

288.9

50.0

67.2

0.0

#6 University of Waterloo

82.4

30.8

22.9

0.0

70.7

197.3

84.9

0.0

___

50.0

23.0

-25.0

#7 Idaho State University

70.7

37.9

24.7

0.0

59.0

0.0

61.2

38.3

___

0.0

49.1

-50.0

#8 University of Wisconsin, Platteville

74.1

36.1

50.0

100.0

68.0

197.3

94.7

75.0

0.0

0.0

50.4

0.0

#10 Minnesota State University

77.0

38.8

0.0

104.3

72.8

247.9

80.8

47.2

0.0

0.0

14.0

0.0

#11 Clarkson University

52.0

34.4

0.3

151.3

74.0

273.8

86.9

25.3

0.0

50.0

57.8

0.0

#13 University of Wisconsin, Madison

87.3

45.6

11.7

183.5

84.8

172.4

86.9

49.9

274.4

50.0

31.9

0.0

#14 Montana Tech

44.8

27.4

22.5

0.0

56.1

0.0

0.0

0.0

___

0.0

0.0

0.0

#16 McGill University

64.0

25.0

9.2

0.0

60.9

0.0

0.0

0.0

___

0.0

0.0

0.0

#17 Ecole de Technologie Superieure

47.8

25.9

37.3

0.0

58.4

197.3

100.0

25.3

0.0

0.0

75.0

0.0

#18 University of Maine

47.6

35.6

28.1

200.0

78.8

197.3

77.3

37.7

247.7

50.0

41.6

-47.6

 

 

Best

Best

Most

Best

               
 

Performance

Design

Practical

Value

TOTAL

FINAL

           
 

Points

Points

Points

Points

POINTS

RANK

           

#1 University of Idaho

____________

____________

NDA

0.000

87

15

           

#2 Michigan Technological University

186

206

0.638

0.206

1000

2

           

#3 Kettering University

____________

____________

0.239

0.163

668

8

           

#4 Colorado State University

____________

____________

0.201

0.159

620

9

           

#5 University at Buffalo, SUNY

181

186

0.406

0.193

917

4

           

#6 University of Waterloo

108

184

NDA

0.155

537

11

           

#7 Idaho State University

____________

____________

NDA

0.150

291

12

           

#8 University of Wisconsin, Platteville

____________

____________

0.262

0.426

746

6

           

#10 Minnesota State University

____________

____________

0.133

0.132

683

7

           

#11 Clarkson University

____________

____________

0.149

0.202

806

5

           

#13 University of Wisconsin, Madison

169

218

0.356

0.320

1078

1

           

#14 Montana Tech

____________

____________

NDA

0.000

151

14

           

#16 McGill University

____________

____________

NDA

0.000

159

13

           

#17 Ecole de Technologie Superieure

____________

____________

0.233

0.236

567

10

           

#18 University of Maine

157

162

0.471

0.430

994

3

           

 

First Place Winner Overall

#13 University of Wisconsin, Madison

   

Second Place Winner Overall

#2 Michigan Technological University

   

Third Place Winner Overall

#18 University of Maine

   

Fourth Place Winner Overall

#5 University at Buffalo, SUNY

   

Fifth Place Winner Overall

#11 Clarkson University

   

Best Performance Winner

#2 Michigan Technological University

   

Best Emissions Winner

#5 University at Buffalo, SUNY

   

Best Design Winner

#13 University of Wisconsin, Madison

   

Best Fuel Economy Winner

#18 University of Maine

   

Quietest Snowmobile Winner

#2 Michigan Technological University

   

Most Practical Winner

#2 Michigan Technological University

   

Best Value Winner

#18 University of Maine

 

the University of Wisconsin Platteville

Best Braking

#8 University of Wisconsin, Platteville

   

Best Acceleration

#17 Ecole de Technologie Superieure

   

Best Handling

#17 Ecole de Technologie Superieure

   

Most Sportsmanlike Winner

#6 University of Waterloo

   

 

SAE CSC2004 Engineering Design Paper Results

 

Eric A.

Bill S.

Jeff G.

David M.

Roger C.

John K.

Jim D.

Don E.

Will P.

Peter J.

Howard H.

Kent H.

Randy A.

Ron B.

Dan K.

Don K.

Mike L.

Tracy D.

POINTS

Ordinal

#1 University of Idaho

88.0

           

79.0

97.0

 

64.0

94.0

 

87.5

 

97.0

   

84.9

4

#2 Michigan Technological University

   

78.0

92.0

     

73.0

   

73.0

90.0

86.0

92.5

       

83.5

5

#3 Kettering University

83.0

   

88.0

77.0

   

77.0

   

90.0

91.0

 

90.0

       

85.1

3

#4 Colorado State University

 

100.0

       

98.0

65.0

   

91.0

95.0

87.0

85.0

       

88.7

1

#5 University at Buffalo, SUNY

91.0

97.0

         

64.0

 

60.0

57.0

69.0

 

52.5

       

70.1

10

#6 University of Waterloo

 

97.0

71.0

     

92.0

55.0

95.0

 

88.0

79.0

           

82.4

6

#7 Idaho State University

 

99.0

64.0

       

63.0

 

55.0

58.0

87.0

69.0

         

70.7

9

#8 University of Wisconsin, Platteville

76.0

           

61.0

92.0

56.0

77.0

82.0

 

75.0

       

74.1

8

#10 Minnesota State University

     

86.0

 

85.0

 

64.0

 

76.0

74.0

     

81.0

   

93.0

77.0

7

#11 Clarkson University

   

45.0

 

58.0

   

40.0

   

52.0

   

65.0

78.0

 

72.0

 

52.0

12

#13 University of Wisconsin, Madison

       

82.0

 

99.0

82.0

   

86.0

     

96.0

91.0

94.0

 

87.3

2

#14 Montana Tech

         

82.0

45.0

31.0

   

46.0

   

20.0

60.0

 

56.0

 

44.8

15

#16 McGill University

         

62.0

67.0

52.0

61.0

 

78.0

     

67.0

   

82.0

64.0

11

#17 Ecole de Technologie Superieure

           

43.0

52.0

   

56.0

 

40.0

 

71.0

70.0

52.0

 

47.8

13

#18 University of Maine

     

38.0

 

71.0

55.0

37.0

   

37.0

     

71.0

   

58.0

47.6

14

 

SAE CSC2004 Static Display Results

 

1

2

3

4

POINTS

Ordinal

#1 University of Idaho

35.0

25.0

44.0

48.0

38.0

7

#2 Michigan Technological University

32.5

42.5

45.0

47.5

41.9

3

#3 Kettering University

37.5

40.0

46.0

43.5

41.8

5

#4 Colorado State University

42.5

50.0

40.0

35.0

41.9

3

#5 University at Buffalo, SUNY

42.0

45.0

42.5

47.5

44.3

2

#6 University of Waterloo

32.5

28.0

40.0

22.5

30.8

12

#7 Idaho State University

37.5

39.0

27.5

47.5

37.9

8

#8 University of Wisconsin, Platteville

29.0

40.0

32.5

43.0

36.1

9

#10 Minnesota State University

45.0

32.5

32.5

45.0

38.8

6

#11 Clarkson University

40.0

42.5

40.0

15.0

34.4

11

#13 University of Wisconsin, Madison

47.5

45.0

50.0

40.0

45.6

1

#14 Montana Tech

20.0

29.0

38.0

22.5

27.4

13

#16 McGill University

15.0

25.0

40.0

20.0

25.0

15

#17 Ecole de Technologie Superieure

30.0

26.0

30.0

17.5

25.9

14

#18 University of Maine

30.0

27.5

35.0

50.0

35.6

10


SAE CSC2004 Technology Implementation Cost Assessment Results

       
   

TITCmax=

$1,868.00

   

TITCmin=

$751.50

       
 

Total Cost

POINTS

Ordinal

#1 University of Idaho

$1,222.50

12.9

11

#2 Michigan Technological University

$902.50

31.7

3

#3 Kettering University

$1,143.46

16.1

9

#4 Colorado State University

$1,107.50

17.8

8

#5 University at Buffalo, SUNY

$1,198.53

13.8

10

#6 University of Waterloo

$1,017.00

22.9

6

#7 Idaho State University

$991.00

24.7

5

#8 University of Wisconsin, Platteville

$751.50

50.0

1

#10 Minnesota State University

$1,868.00

0.0

15

#11 Clarkson University

$1,839.45

0.3

14

#13 University of Wisconsin, Madison

$1,255.27

11.7

12

#14 Montana Tech

$1,024.25

22.5

7

#16 McGill University

$1,338.00

9.2

13

#17 Ecole de Technologie Superieure

$847.50

37.3

2

#18 University of Maine

$944.94

28.1

4


SAE CSC2004 Fuel Economy/Endurance Results

   

Gmax =

7.62

gallons

(Max gallons used of finishing teams)

 
     

Gmin =

4.73

gallons

(Min gallons used of finishing teams)

 
     

Distance=

89.0

miles

(Course distance)

 
               
 

Fuel Type

Gallons Consumed

Fuel Economy (MPG)

POINTS

Ordinal

 

% Improve

#1 University of Idaho

 

DNF

DNF

0

6

 

DNF

#2 Michigan Technological University

 

DNF

DNF

0

6

 

DNF

#3 Kettering University

 

DNF

DNF

0

6

 

DNF

#4 Colorado State University

 

DNF

DNF

0

6

 

DNF

#5 University at Buffalo, SUNY

 

DNF

DNF

0

6

 

DNF

#6 University of Waterloo

 

DNF

DNF

0

6

 

DNF

#7 Idaho State University

 

DNF

DNF

0

6

 

DNF

#8 University of Wisconsin, Platteville

E10

7.62

11.7

100

5

 

-23.5%

#10 Minnesota State University

E85

7.37

12.1

104

4

 

-20.9%

#11 Clarkson University

E10

5.65

15.8

151

3

 

3.2%

#13 University of Wisconsin, Madison

E10

4.99

17.8

183

2

 

16.8%

#14 Montana Tech

 

DNF

DNF

0

6

 

DNF

#16 McGill University

 

DNF

DNF

0

6

 

DNF

#17 Ecole de Technologie Superieure

 

DNF

DNF

0

6

 

DNF

#18 University of Maine

E10

4.73

18.8

200

1

 

23.3%

Control Snowmobile

E10

5.83

15.3

       


SAE CSC2004 Oral Presentation Results

                           
 

Jim D.

Jim E.

Bill S.

Eric L.

Randy A.

Dan K.

Ron B.

Gereard K.

Tracy D.

Trig N.

Peter J.

POINTS

Ordinal

#1 University of Idaho

55.0

67.5

72.5

60.0

79.0

85.0

87.5

92.0

87.5

66.0

82.0

75.8

4

#2 Michigan Technological University

80.0

70.0

82.5

62.5

83.0

88.0

97.5

92.0

82.5

74.0

74.0

80.5

2

#3 Kettering University

75.0

51.5

67.5

52.5

58.0

75.0

82.5

82.0

50.0

52.0

72.0

65.3

11

#4 Colorado State University

75.0

52.5

87.5

60.0

68.0

89.0

80.0

93.0

72.5

55.0

74.0

73.3

6

#5 University at Buffalo, SUNY

60.0

50.5

75.0

65.0

73.0

78.0

92.5

88.0

77.5

63.0

62.0

71.3

8

#6 University of Waterloo

73.0

52.5

65.0

60.0

65.0

77.0

85.0

90.0

77.5

67.5

65.0

70.7

9

#7 Idaho State University

67.5

34.0

65.0

42.5

54.0

72.0

72.5

80.0

57.5

45.0

 

59.0

13

#8 University of Wisconsin, Platteville

65.0

70.0

62.5

45.0

62.0

73.0

70.0

85.0

75.0

72.5

68.0

68.0

10

#10 Minnesota State University

80.0

60.0

75.0

55.0

55.0

77.0

85.0

93.0

77.5

65.0

78.0

72.8

7

#11 Clarkson University

82.5

56.5

80.0

57.5

60.0

79.0

90.0

90.0

80.0

74.0

65.0

74.0

5

#13 University of Wisconsin, Madison

80.0

82.0

95.0

80.0

71.0

97.0

97.5

94.0

85.0

67.0

84.0

84.8

1

#14 Montana Tech

40.0

47.5

57.5

35.0

59.0

70.0

52.5

82.0

57.5

52.5

64.0

56.1

15

#16 McGill University

65.0

48.0

65.0

22.5

52.0

69.0

60.0

89.0

65.0

80.0

54.0

60.9

12

#17 Ecole de Technologie Superieure

50.0

50.0

55.0

52.5

54.0

67.0

52.5

80.0

70.0

47.5

64.0

58.4

14

#18 University of Maine

95.0

42.0

82.5

55.0

75.0

94.0

100.0

92.0

80.0

78.0

73.0

78.8

3


SAE CSC2004 Noise Testing

         
     

dBAmin=

107.5

 
           
 

Run1 dBA

Run2 dBA

Avg dBA

POINTS

Ordinal

#1 University of Idaho

DNF

DNF

 

0.0

12

#2 Michigan Technological University

108

107

107.5

300.0

1

#3 Kettering University

108

108

108.0

273.8

2

#4 Colorado State University

108

110

109.0

222.4

5

#5 University at Buffalo, SUNY

109

110

109.5

197.3

6

#6 University of Waterloo

110

109

109.5

197.3

6

#7 Idaho State University

DNF

DNF

 

0.0

12

#8 University of Wisconsin, Platteville

109

110

109.5

197.3

6

#10 Minnesota State University

109

108

108.5

247.9

4

#11 Clarkson University

108

108

108.0

273.8

2

#13 University of Wisconsin, Madison

110

110

110.0

172.4

11

#14 Montana Tech

DNF

DNF

 

0.0

12

#16 McGill University

DNF

DNF

 

0.0

12

#17 Ecole de Technologie Superieure

109

110

109.5

197.3

6

#18 University of Maine

110

109

109.5

197.3

6

Control Snowmobile

112

111

111.5

   


SAE CSC2004 Acceleration Results

     

Tmin=

7.170

sec

   
               
 

Run1 Time (s)

Run2 Time (s)

Best Time (s)

POINTS

Ordinal

 

% Improve

#1 University of Idaho

DNF

DNF

DNF

0.0

13

 

DNF

#2 Michigan Technological University

7.700

DNF

7.700

89.7

4

 

9.6%

#3 Kettering University

7.380

8.450

7.380

95.6

2

 

13.4%

#4 Colorado State University

9.020

10.340

9.020

71.4

11

 

-5.9%

#5 University at Buffalo, SUNY

8.440

8.090

8.090

83.3

8

 

5.0%

#6 University of Waterloo

8.280

7.990

7.990

84.9

7

 

6.2%

#7 Idaho State University

10.130

10.720

10.130

61.2

12

 

-18.9%

#8 University of Wisconsin, Platteville

7.430

7.810

7.430

94.7

3

 

12.8%

#10 Minnesota State University

8.260

8.410

8.260

80.8

9

 

3.1%

#11 Clarkson University

8.730

7.860

7.860

86.9

5

 

7.7%

#13 University of Wisconsin, Madison

7.890

7.860

7.860

86.9

5

 

7.7%

#14 Montana Tech

DNF

DNF

DNF

0.0

13

 

DNF

#16 McGill University

DNF

DNF

DNF

0.0

13

 

DNF

#17 Ecole de Technologie Superieure

7.170

7.390

7.170

100.0

1

 

15.8%

#18 University of Maine

8.800

8.520

8.520

77.3

10

 

0.0%

Control

9.190

8.520

8.520

       


SAE CSC2004 Brake Testing Results

     

BDmax=

168.28

feet

     

BDmin=

117.20

feet

           
 

Run1 Dist (Feet)

Run2 Dist (Feet)

Average Dist (Feet)

POINTS

Ordinal

#1 University of Idaho

DNF

DNF

DNF

0.0

12

#2 Michigan Technological University

112.670

129.930

121.30

65.3

2

#3 Kettering University

125.700

136.590

131.15

45.7

6

#4 Colorado State University

145.900

107.300

126.60

54.2

3

#5 University at Buffalo, SUNY

132.390

148.980

140.69

30.4

9

#6 University of Waterloo

187.520

149.040

168.28

0.0

12

#7 Idaho State University

143.620

127.450

135.54

38.3

7

#8 University of Wisconsin, Platteville

124.960

109.440

117.20

75.0

1

#10 Minnesota State University

117.670

142.920

130.30

47.2

5

#11 Clarkson University

136.750

152.010

144.38

25.3

10

#13 University of Wisconsin, Madison

131.440

126.250

128.85

49.9

4

#14 Montana Tech

DNF

DNF

DNF

0.0

12

#16 McGill University

DNF

DNF

DNF

0.0

12

#17 Ecole de Technologie Superieure

154.110

134.760

144.44

25.3

11

#18 University of Maine

136.650

135.170

135.91

37.7

8

Control

128.83

102.19

128.13

118.86

 
 

Morning

 

Evening

   

 

SAE CSC2004 Emission Testing Results

 

FINAL COMPOSITE EMISSIONS (g/kW-hr)

           

PERCENT REDUCTION IN POLLUTANT

     
                       
 

CO

UHC

NOx

UHC+NOx

POINTS

Ordinal

 

CO

UHC

NOx

UHC+NOx

#1 University of Idaho

DNF

DNF

DNF

DNF

DNF

DNF

 

DNF

DNF

DNF

DNF

#2 Michigan Technological University

59.430

1.240

3.850

5.090

275.77

2

 

40.5%

89.2%

83.5%

85.4%

#3 Kettering University

210.510

8.360

0.090

8.450

0.00

5

 

-110.8%

27.2%

99.6%

75.7%

#4 Colorado State University

122.990

32.550

4.470

37.020

0.00

5

 

-23.2%

-183.5%

80.8%

-6.3%

#5 University at Buffalo, SUNY

36.530

1.270

6.300

7.570

288.90

1

 

63.4%

88.9%

73.0%

78.3%

#6 University of Waterloo

DNF

DNF

DNF

DNF

DNF

DNF

 

DNF

DNF

DNF

DNF

#7 Idaho State University

DNF

DNF

DNF

DNF

DNF

DNF

 

DNF

DNF

DNF

DNF

#8 University of Wisconsin, Platteville

333.62

7.08

0.26

7.340

0.00

5

 

-234.2%

38.3%

98.9%

78.9%

#10 Minnesota State University

204.250

1.370

2.410

3.780

0.00

5

 

-104.6%

88.1%

89.7%

89.1%

#11 Clarkson University

205.010

3.220

0.400

3.620

0.00

5

 

-105.3%

72.0%

98.3%

89.6%

#13 University of Wisconsin, Madison

57.210

2.020

3.890

5.910

274.45

3

 

42.7%

82.4%

83.3%

83.0%

#14 Montana Tech

DNF

DNF

DNF

DNF

DNF

DNF

 

DNF

DNF

DNF

DNF

#16 McGill University

DNF

DNF

DNF

DNF

DNF

DNF

 

DNF

DNF

DNF

DNF

#17 Ecole de Technologie Superieure

435.07

277.900

3.7

281.640

0.00

5

 

-335.8%

-2320.7%

84.0%

-709.1%

#18 University of Maine

63.05

9.210

1.3

10.510

247.68

4

 

36.8%

19.8%

94.4%

69.8%

Control Snowmobile

99.840

11.480

23.330

34.810

             
                       

COmin=

36.530

 

UHC+NOXmin=

5.090

             

 

SAE CSC2004 Cold Start Results

         
 

Result (PASS/FAIL)

SCORE

   

#1 University of Idaho

Fail

0

   

#2 Michigan Technological University

Fail

0

   

#3 Kettering University

Fail

0

   

#4 Colorado State University

Pass

50

   

#5 University at Buffalo, SUNY

Pass

50

   

#6 University of Waterloo

Pass

50

   

#7 Idaho State University

Fail

0

   

#8 University of Wisconsin, Platteville

Fail

0

   

#10 Minnesota State University

Fail

0

   

#11 Clarkson University

Pass

50

   

#13 University of Wisconsin, Madison

Pass

50

   

#14 Montana Tech

Fail

0

   

#16 McGill University

Fail

0

   

#17 Ecole de Technologie Superieure

Fail

0

   

#18 University of Maine

Pass

50

   


SAE CSC2004 Handling/Driveability Event Results

     

Tmax =

60.9

sec

     

Tmin =

47.4

sec

           
 

Run1 Lap Time (s)

Run2 Lap Time (s)

Minimum Lap Time (s)

POINTS

Ordinal

#1 University of Idaho

DNF

DNF

DNF

0.0

12

#2 Michigan Technological University

55.00

54.00

54

31.3

9

#3 Kettering University

51.70

52.50

51.7

44.7

6

#4 Colorado State University

60.90

61.60

60.9

0.0

12

#5 University at Buffalo, SUNY

48.40

55.60

48.4

67.2

2

#6 University of Waterloo

59.40

55.60

55.6

23.0

10

#7 Idaho State University

51.20

51.00

51.00

49.1

5

#8 University of Wisconsin, Platteville

50.80

58.60

50.8

50.4

4

#10 Minnesota State University

57.50

57.55

57.5

14.0

11

#11 Clarkson University

49.70

52.00

49.7

57.8

3

#13 University of Wisconsin, Madison

53.90

57.25

53.9

31.9

8

#14 Montana Tech

DNF

DNF

DNF

0.0

12

#16 McGill University

DNF

DNF

DNF

0.0

12

#17 Ecole de Technologie Superieure

47.40

50.55

47.4

75.0

1

#18 University of Maine

52.20

52.30

52.2

41.6

7

Control

56.60

58.15

56.6

18.2

 
           


SAE CSC2003 Penalties

               
 

Late Oral

Late Paper

Late Snowmobile

Safety Violation

Maintence

Drafting

SCORE

#1 University of Idaho

       

-125

 

-125

#2 Michigan Technological University

           

0

#3 Kettering University

           

0

#4 Colorado State University

           

0

#5 University at Buffalo, SUNY

           

0

#6 University of Waterloo

       

-25

 

-25

#7 Idaho State University

       

-50

 

-50

#8 University of Wisconsin, Platteville

           

0

#10 Minnesota State University

           

0

#11 Clarkson University

           

0

#13 University of Wisconsin, Madison

           

0

#14 Montana Tech

           

0

#16 McGill University

           

0

#17 Ecole de Technologie Superieure

           

0

#18 University of Maine

 

-47.6

       

-47.6