Search Committees
When it comes to actually recruiting diverse faculty/staff members, many search committees report that they cannot find qualified women or people of color to apply for their open positions. Research, however, has shown that committees succeed in hiring women and people of color when they transform the search process, are committed to diversity and are proactive about building a diverse applicant pool.
Transforming the search process requires that the committee do more than simply place ads and wait for applicants to express interest. Search committees can use personal and professional networks of existing faculty, staff and students, and discipline-based organizations, and take advantage of publications and web sites that specialize in the recruitment of diverse faculty members. The following tips can help committees transform the search process.
Existing Faculty, Staff, and Students - Use existing faculty, staff and graduate students to market open positions. Ask faculty, staff and students to take along copies of the job announcement when they travel to academic conferences and meetings. Further, ask that they contact their colleagues and inquire about promising graduate students or new scholars from underrepresented groups. When using faculty, staff, and students in this manner it is important to encourage them to seek candidates beyond those who are most like themselves.
All academic disciplines have professional organizations associated with them. Many have subcommittees on women and/or people of color. In addition, most have both national and regional meetings, newsletters, email mailing lists and web sites. These organizational resources can be key in departmental recruiting efforts. Poll faculty members to determine which organizations are active in the discipline area related to the open faculty position. Distribute job announcements to regional contacts or committee chairs. Follow-up with phone calls to discuss the department's needs and how best to identify promising scholars in the field.
The Search Committee
- Membership on the committee should be reserved for individuals who thoroughly understand the requirements of the position to be filled and who are committed to the mission of the department and the University.
- The search committee should be composed of individuals from diverse backgrounds in order to provide a variety of perspectives, as well as sensitivity to affirmative action issues.
- Search committees should have a minority and/or woman as a member or consultant. When possible, women and minorities from the department should be represented on all Search committees. Care should be taken not to overburden these few people with many committee assignments.
- Women and minorities from other departments may be enlisted to serve on these committees.
- Contact Human Resources for help on selecting search committee members.
- Include individuals with different perspectives, expertise and a demonstrated commitment to diversity.
- Identify two or three key members who will serve as advocates for women and minorities.
- Ask that your Dean meet with the committee at the beginning of the process to reiterate the importance of inclusion, the advisory role of the committee and the need for confidentiality.
- Emphasize preference for all inquiries and requests to be referred to the chairperson.
- Determine how committee members will communicate with each other, the campus community and with candidates.
Affirmative Action Representative
The search committee should designate one member to be the "Affirmative Action Representative."
- This individual should evaluate all steps of the search process in terms of the goals and principles of affirmative action, including seeing to it that the position is widely advertised and that the search committee does not unconsciously engage in discriminatory practices.
- This person may be responsible for ensuring that networking to minority and female candidates takes place.
- This person need not be a woman or minority.
- The representative (as well as the chair and other committee members) is invited to contact the Affirmative Programs Office anytime during the search process.
The Committee Charge
One useful suggestion is to give committee members a formal, written "charge to the committee," a memo setting forth the institution's expectations for the position and the search committee's role in helping to fill it. Typically a search-committee charge covers the following essentials:
- Most importantly, the character of the position to be filled as the institution now views it, extending beyond a job description (which should be attached) to a description of short and longer-term needs/opportunities raised by the vacancy.
- The tasks and role of the committee in the search, and of its chair.
- Any institutional sense of scope or limits to the search (e.g., internal, local, statewide, national).
- A preferred time by which the appointment should be made.
- Essential characteristics the institution desires in the names brought forward (e.g., relating to goals for diversity, national reputation, related college experience, etc.)
- Instruction as to the form in which the committee's final recommendations are to be brought forward.
- A sense of what steps (if any) the appointing officer desires to participate in or be consulted about.
- If a search firm or consultants will be in the picture, their role in relation to the committee.
- A description of the search related financial and office resources available to the committee.
- A reference to governmental and institutional regulations applicable to this search, including needs for record keeping.
- The role of the committee, if any, after it submits it's recommendations.
Your Role as a Search Committee Member
- Be aware of EEO/AA laws (admin.mtu.edu/aao/laws.htm), requirements and obligations. The Affirmative Programs Director is available to meet with search committees.
- Don't take old practices for granted. Practices that were once acceptable and traditional may be illegal today.
- Avoid stereotypes (admin.mtu.edu/aao/intv.htm#stereotypes) or preconceptions.
- Help recruit. Tell friends and people of protected groups about the job opening.
- Speak out if someone is showing discriminatory attitudes.
- Review the Human Resources Interview Committee Information Booklet
(admin.mtu.edu/hro/forms/interviewcommitteeinfo.pdf).
Search Steps
Think beyond the immediate search steps as you develop your procedures. Just as you are trying to find the best candidate, applicants are judging whether they want to come to the University. In order to impress applicants it's important to have an organized, professional hiring process.
- Plan the Search
- Meet with the appropriate faculty and staff to review the needs of the department and develop specific hiring goals. This is an excellent point in the process to determine whether the subject specialty of the position will include issues of race, gender, etc., and the degree of departmental commitment to assuring that candidates are sensitive to working with a diverse student population.
- Develop a clear position description, with Human Resources, that includes minimum qualifications and experience desired. Get departmental or school consensus on areas of specialty and other specific requirements.
- Seek appropriate approvals before circulating the job announcement and/or advertisement. The Human Resource Office, Affirmative Programs Office, and in some cases, the appropriate department head must approve the language of all advertisements.
- Develop a realistic timeline for recruiting and interviewing, working backwards from a target completion date.
- Establish a system for managing records, including nominations, applications, letters to candidates, affirmative action forms and search committee notes.
- Document how the committee will actively recruit women and minorities.
- Discuss confidentiality issues with committee members.
- Be clear on what the role of the committee is. In some cases the committee is authorized only to recommend the final candidates to be invited for interviews. In others, the committee identifies the candidates, coordinates the on-campus interview process and makes a hiring recommendation to the appropriate department head.
- Market the Position & Michigan Tech
- Determine which professional networks, web sites and publications will be used for marketing the job announcement. See Advertising Resources (admin.mtu.edu/aao/res.htm#recruitment).
- Develop two information packets: one to be sent to all candidates upon receipt of their application; and the second to be sent only to candidates selected for an interview. Include brochures about the campus and local community.
- Place the job announcement on the department or school web page. Make sure to include the Equal Employment Opporturnity Statement (admin.mtu.edu/aao/adv.htm#statements) on the web page.
- Identify campus resources to assist with the marketing. Encourage women, minorities, and campus community to identify and nominate potential candidates.
- Have material prepared for committee members or departmental faculty to make personal contact with potential candidates at professional meetings and conferences.
- Develop Selection Criteria
- Develop a list of selection criteria for rating candidate applications based on the job description.
- Reach committee consensus on how different qualifications will be weighted.
- Communication
- Faculty Only: Acknowledge all applications and letters in writing and enclose the Equal Employment Opportunity Self Disclosure Form (admin.mtu.edu/aao/eeform.htm#EEO).
- Develop a way to keep the department informed without breaching confidentiality.
- The search committee chair has primary responsibility for communicating with the Dean, Department Chair, Director, or department head regarding the process and applicant pool.
- Evaluate the Applicant Pool
- Include all committee members in the evaluation process.
- Use predetermined selection criteria to rate applications on minimum and preferred qualifications.
- Faculty only: Identify top candidates, and review Faculty Recruitment Report with Affirmative Programs Office before proceeding.
- Faculty only: Notify those not selected for further consideration.
- Prepare for the Interview and Reference Checks
- Develop a consistent set of questions to be asked of each candidate and determine how the answers will be rated.
- Determine whether or not telephone interviews will be conducted for a short list of semi-finalists.
- Develop a consistent set of questions for checking references. Know the rules for your college, school, or department.
- Conduct references before candidates are invited to campus. As a professional courtesy, secure permission from the candidate before contacting references.
- Develop a short list of candidates to be invited to campus for further interviews.
- NOTE: Consider interviewing more than one woman. Research shows that interviewers more fairly evaluate women when there is more than one woman in the candidate pool (Valian, Virginia (1999) Why So Slow? The Advancement of Women. Cambridge, Mass: The MIT Press. See especially Chapter 7).
- Follow school or college procedures regarding the final list before contacting candidates.
- Interview
- As appropriate to the school or college, develop an interview schedule that includes: time with the search committee; meetings with students, faculty and University personnel; a seminar presentation; and hosted lunch and/or dinner. See Suggestions for Interviews.
- Know the procedures for travel expenses and reimbursement (admin.mtu.edu/aao/intv.htm#reimbursement) for entertainment.
- Offer all candidates information on whom to contact to discuss any special requirements or circumstances, such as disability accommodations. Keep in mind that committee members cannot ask candidates about their marital status or disability.
- NOTE: Remember even informal & social gatherings, as part of the interview schedule, are still under Affirmative Action Interview Guidelines.
- Conclude and Wrap-up
- Solicit written remarks from those that met with or interviewed candidates.
- Be sure to document the search process and final candidate rankings, including completion of the Faculty Recruitment Report or the Staff Hiring Activity Record and the Applicant Flow Log. See Affirmative Action Procedures (admin.mtu.edu/aao/aapro.htm#AAP).
- For faculty positions see Faculty Hiring Guide (admin.mtu.edu/admin/prov/hiring/index.htm) for materials to be included in the appointment packet. Additional search documentation may be required by the college or school (e.g., a letter from the chair of the search committee to the Dean).
- Send a formal letter as soon as candidate has accepted final position offer.